Rufus on Fire: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
New Blog: Cowboy Altitude for Wyoming Fans!

Stephen Curry and Our TV Broadcast Team

Tomorrow, the Bobcats play in Oakland against the Golden State Warriors. Facing the Dubs is always a weird game for me, because I was born and raised in San Francisco. Among my high school friends, if they're hoops fans, they're Warriors fans.

On the court, it'll be fascinating to see what the Cats do against a team made up of several legit NBA starters plus a bunch of D-League All Stars. Old friend Cartier Martin is in the mix, along with C.J. Watson and Anthony Tolliver. I'd argue that Vladimir Radmanovic is at about their level at this point, and the team is probably just riding out his contract.

But, of course, there's one player that's going to get the most attention in game recaps from Carolina-based reporters, and, especially, the TV broadcast: Stephen Curry.

Star-divide

Generally, I leave announcers alone because, having done it professionally myself, I have an idea of how difficult the job can be and how the momentary slipups that we never notice in our everyday lives can be extracted, separated, and held up for all to see in the broadcast medium. However, I'm not comfortable with the way Steve Martin, Stephanie Ready, and Dell Curry have been discussing this upcoming game, especially as it relates to Curry's son.

There's something admirable about confronting the issue head on and making no apologies for their feelings, as they have, but I can't be the only one who feels... I don't know... a little icky after listening to our play by play man and our color commentator and our sideline reporter slash color commentator gushing about Stephen.

I guess the issue is this: I want to listen to and read people who are up front about their biases and their favorites and such, but they have to be fair, ultimately, and I get the feeling that they're not going to be fair when describing the game to us. I try to ride this line, myself. To pick an old issue, I'm completely in the can for Emeka Okafor. I love the guy as a basketball player, and I've long felt he's the kind of guy that every team in the league could use. But even though I bought the man's jersey, made sure that he'd be the first one I mentioned in a song I wrote about the Bobcats, and told everyone who would listen that he and Gerald Wallace were the most important pieces of the Cats' present and future, I was still perfectly capable of pointing out that he was limited on offense until he started developing a fifteen-foot turnaround, and even then, he was better off only unleashing it once or twice a game.

If Stephen Curry does something stupid, will our announcers tell us they noticed it? If Gerald Wallace fouls Curry hard in the lane, starting some shoving, will our announcers take a side? Take Bill Walton for an example. He never hid that he was Luke Walton's dad, but you'd never hear him gush about Luke as a sweet passing point forward who would allow the Lakers to play with Kobe and another guard off the ball. When Bill strapped on the mic, he had enough respect for the game and national viewers to be realistic about who Luke was and where he was going. I'm not sure it's possible for our broadcast crew to assess Stephen Curry as Eddie House with a few more steals.

It's not just a matter of preferring one style over another, and this sort of thing isn't just some harmless fun. The TV broadcast team shapes viewers' perceptions of the game and the players. I'm not worried that the hardcore fans, the basketball nerds that watch every night and jump on their favorite web sites to talk hoops with other people, are going to be affected. I'm worried that if they dispense with the usual tone, if they're willing to openly gloss over truth for one player, then it means they're willing to gloss over the truth about anything, openly or not. I hope they don't.

0 recs  |  Comment 18 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Homers

I doubt Steve and Dell will show any restraint. They are local/regional broadcasters who take pride in the fact that they are homers. They root for the local/regional teams and the players who come from or who played in those areas. Walton, Bilas, and Gminski do their thing on a national level. Therefore, they seem to make a more concerted effort to keep their biases hidden.

The Suns announcers were gushing over Boris during the PHX game. Their Lou Holtz-esque bias was a little annoying to me. I can only imagine what the Suns’ fans thought.

"I could never be a thug, they don't dress this well." - Malice

by Julius Coxswain on Jan 28, 2010 11:56 AM EST reply actions  

I personally enjoy opinionated broadcasters. National broadcasters who arent alowed to have an opinion are boring and predictable. Local brodcasters wear their heart on their sleeve and its always intresting.

by Bcat2.0 on Jan 28, 2010 12:22 PM EST reply actions  

I might agree with you to an extent, but have you ever tried listening to the Chicago White Sox announcers? I think there is a fine line between showing a little favoritism and going too far.

by CarolinaDodger on Jan 28, 2010 1:00 PM EST up reply actions  

Curry=Eddie House with more steals???

Come on now, Curry is no Steve Nash but saying he is just House with a few more steals is a low blow.

by alwalte2 on Jan 28, 2010 12:24 PM EST reply actions  

I’m not saying he is Eddie House. Just saying that it’s clearly unthinkable they’d express such an opinion of him. The larger point is that they’re not really sharing insight if they can’t be bluntly honest about what they’re seeing.

by David A. Arnott on Jan 29, 2010 12:14 AM EST up reply actions  

I’m glad Martin, Ready, and Curry are putting it out in the open about Stephen. I was actually wondering this same thing leading up to this game because Martin has made comments about GS and Stephen in some previous games this season.

I think they will root for the Cats and will just give Dell a hard time regardless if his son starts messing up or performing well. I haven’t noticed all the gushing mentioned in this article but I have noticed the good humored ridicule.

I can’t believe the author had a Chokafor jersey. lol. That explains alot. I don’t see what the big deal was about Chokafor. He had two left feet, stone hands, no mobility, no excitement, no enthusiasm, no passion. He was VERY robotic and stiff, he had to play out of position because he didn’t have the quickness and skill to play the four, his natural position, and he would get his shots blocked ALOT :)

"It's a bad day to have a bad day" - Coach John Fox of the Carolina Panthers

by D.W.G. on Jan 28, 2010 12:24 PM EST reply actions  

True.

But sometimes the announcers’ silly statements can be grating as you are trying to watch the game. You can try muting it, but that’s probably worse.

by CharginChuck on Jan 28, 2010 5:09 PM EST up reply actions  

If you don’t think the announcers add anything to the game, don’t bring any insight, that’s probably more damning than anything I’ve written here.

by David A. Arnott on Jan 29, 2010 12:15 AM EST up reply actions  

I'd say it's less damning

and more and statement about the lack of impact that most announcers have on the game watching experience. As long as they’re not being totally annoying they can have whatever opinion they want.

I just think you come up w/ some silly things to gripe about. That’s the damning comment.

by and1droid on Jan 29, 2010 10:15 AM EST up reply actions  

I'm glad that Del is proud of his son.

He’s also taken some ribbing from the others on the broadcast team. I think it makes the trio look more like a family or a tight-knit group of friends. Networks push hard to give the appearance that their announcing teams are the best of buddies because the world of sports is like a group of giant fraternities and the brotherhood aspect is expected. They even tried to make it seem like Dennis MIller was the most welcome thing on Monday Night Football since the invention of beer. I think most everyone that suffered through any of his broadcasts was well aware that the others in the booth might be “making nice” but that in reality they despised him more than the XFL. In the case of Del, Steven, and Stephanie though, I often sense some genuine affection there. I don’t think there’s any chance Stephanie will be sitting at the Martin Thanksgiving table anytime soon, but I don’t get a lot of animosity between them beyond her sometime annoyance at the deliberately tacky intoductions Martin often uses to hand things off to her. (“So head on out for some Bojangles chicken. Speaking of Bojangles, the only thing more welcome right now than some legs and dirty rice is an update from our own Stephanie…”)

So for one game Del wears his heart on his sleeve. I imagine he’ll be pulling for the Bobcats to win while pulling for his son to have a strong game at the same time. I also imagine he’s not looking forward to the comments he’s going to have to endure from Martin every time Stephen bricks a free throw or passes the ball to a cameraman instead of a cutter. The game is going to be a golden opportunity for some needling between the announcers to turn into hard feelings. I’d LOVE to be in earshot during the commercial breaks. (“There’s a time out on the court and we’re going to take a break as well… Okay Martin, you diss my boy one more time and this old number 30 is gonna raise some cartoon knots on your head.”)

Am I on the money here? Probably not, but it’s fun to imagine it going down like that.

The reality is that whether the trio loves or hates one another they all have one thing in common – they love the paycheck they get for the gig and they aren’t going to risk losing it.
I personally would much rather hear Del openly beam with pride and brag on his boy than hear him pull the faked detachment bullcrap so commonly heard from national sportscasters. He might even get personal with it in ways that will make the game even more interesting. ("Man, all those years of one-on-one in the backyard and he STILL can’t move to the left to prevent a drive… " “Did you see the way he squared his shoulders to the basket before letting fly with that 3? My boy’s doin’ it right.”)

I’d welcome that. One of the big goals for a sports broadcaster (and I’m sure David can back me on this) is that he seem like one of the guys. Kinda like the guy in your regular gang that comes over for the game and always seems to have the stats at his fingertips. Most people know the guy at the mic has a team of experts feeding him the info, and some even give a shoutout to the ones that pass on a particular juicy stat, but most try to make it sound like they had the knowledge to begin with. It’s just like Trebeck on Jeopardy. Millions of people think he’s a major braniac even though the correct “question” is sitting right on the card he’s holding in his hand.(“No, I’m sorry. The correct response is, ‘What is 3 times 143.2 to the third power.’”)

What better way to make Del seem like part of the posse than to have him brag a little on his boy? What better way to make Steven and Steph part of the gang than to have them crack a bit on Del when Stephen messes up? It’s exactly what would happen amongst all of us if we got together at a sports bar or at one of our own kids’ high school games. (“Hey ourday? Did you teach him to shoot airballs like that, or is that just his natural skills comin’ out?”)

by Ourdaywillcome on Jan 28, 2010 3:19 PM EST reply actions  

Sounds a little bit whiney

I don’t understand where this complaint comes from. You worry that they won’t criticize Steph for doing something wrong, but they rarely criticize anyone. That’s one thing I really like about our broadcast team is that they are relatively neutral in the way they call the game and they are pretty positive. They almost never criticize the refs or opposing players. So why would Dell go out of his way to criticize his son?

I finally finished school and got a real job so I was able to order the league pass this season. You can’t complain about our team if you’ve watched any other games. Sean Elliot is the worst color commentator ever. That is extreme bias. The Rockets announcers are awful in their lack of neutrality. I guess you can’t appreciate how good you have it until you’ve seen the other side. I hope Steph has a great game and I hope Dell has a great time watching.

Stephen Curry = Eddie House with more steals? That’s just insulting and either ignorant or bitter (about what I don’t know, but this post wreaks of bitterness about something).

by drapht00 on Jan 28, 2010 4:55 PM EST reply actions  

As noted above, I’m not saying he is Eddie House, just that Martin and Curry have shown they’re incapable of holding such an opinion of him. In theory, they’re providing insight into the game that their privileged perch gives them. If they can’t/don’t provide it, then we ought to bring in someone who will, otherwise we may as well go announcerless. I’ll bring this up again tomorrow, but it struck me later this evening that they could have made Stephanie Ready the color commentator for the game and told Dell to take the night off.

by David A. Arnott on Jan 29, 2010 12:19 AM EST up reply actions  

Lol if he gets fouled hard Dell will give his own team's player an ear full.

Also the House comparison is stupid. House = shooter Curry = does everything at point guard

Rookie: "Why did you bench me?"
Nellie: "You're a rookie"

by dubzfan on Jan 28, 2010 5:13 PM EST reply actions  

I'm not sure either.
I’m not sure it’s possible for our broadcast crew to assess Stephen Curry as Eddie House with a few more steals.

I am sure that it is NOT possible for anyone to ACCURATELY assess Stephen Curry as “Eddie House with a few more steals.”

In Curry’s brief NBA career he has averaged twice the amounts of minutes and points as House has in his career; 3 times the rebounds, 3 times the steals, 4.6 times the amount of assists, a higher fg%, ft% & 3pt%. Not to mention that Curry has started 41 games this season — House has started 44 games in his entire career. (And Curry’s coach Don Nelson is almost as infamous for NOT playing rookies as LB).

NOT in 1 of House’s 10 NBA seasons – not even his best season statistically – has House put up numbers anywhere close to those that Curry has put up in his first NBA season.

I certainly hope that our announcers do not assess Stephen Curry as being anything like Eddie House, because that would be by far the stupidest thing i have ever heard Dell, Steve, or Stephanie ever say —and I have heard Steve Martin say some stupid shit. Curry is so much of a superior player to Eddie House, that i feel we are all stupider for having even entertained such a notion.

by dudemanhey on Jan 29, 2010 1:16 AM EST reply actions  

Per/36 for House’s career:
15.9 pts, 3.3 ast, 41% FG, 39% 3P

Per/36 for Curry, before he hits the rookie wall:
14.7 pts, 4.9 ast, 46% FG, 43% 3P

House was a similarly styled prospect coming out of a better college conference, with similar questions about his ability to play PG and defend anyone. Curry’s probably going to be better, but it’s not out of the question he ends up following House’s career path.

by David A. Arnott on Jan 29, 2010 8:50 AM EST up reply actions  

what stands out to me is 41% to 46% that 5% is the difference between an effective offensive player and a guy who has no shot selection. the assist also stand out can anyone say House is a better playmaker than Curry? That said Curry is only a Rookie Playing the hardest position in Basketball, he can only get better.

by Bcat2.0 on Jan 29, 2010 3:22 PM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Charlotte Bobcats.
Start posting about the Bobcats »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

SBNation.com Recent Stories

NEW YORK CITY NY - AUGUST 12:  Kevin Durant #5 looks on during the World Basketball Festival USAB Showcase at Radio City Music Hall on August 12 2010 in New York City. (Photo by Chris Trotman/Getty Images for Nike) +4 updates

FIBA World Championships 2010: Team USA Routs Iran 88-51, Clinches Top Spot In Group B

Cleveland Cavaliers' Delonte West, right, shoot over Indiana Pacers' Jeff Foster in the first half of a NBA basketball game in Indianapolis, Monday, April 13, 2009.  (AP Photo/Michael Conroy) link

Celtics Sign Free Agent Delonte West

Rose +2 updates

FIBA World Championships 2010: Team USA Ekes Out 70-68 Win Over Brazil

More from SBNation.com >


Managers

2285436864_6a38df6622_m_small David A. Arnott